Co-founder and CEO of Netflix Reed Hastings attends a pink carpet for the Netflix launch at Palazzo Del Ghiaccio on October 22, 2015 in Milan, Italy.
Jacopo Raule | Getty Pictures
Netflix‘s second-quarter earnings outcomes might be interpreted in two very alternative ways. The corporate’s future depends upon which studying seems to be appropriate.
The world’s greatest streaming firm introduced Tuesday that it misplaced practically 1 million subscribers for the three-month interval from April to June, marking the second straight quarter it misplaced prospects. Nonetheless, that was lower than the lack of 2 million the corporate had forecast and Netflix shares have been up about 6% at $214 in noon buying and selling Wednesday.
The second-quarter outcomes supply a brand new bull case for Netflix traders. If the quarter serves as a “backside” — the purpose at which Netflix stopped shedding subscribers and began rising once more, even when at a snail’s tempo — traders have a brand new development story. Within the subsequent quarter, Netflix forecast it might add 1 million subscribers. This can be the first cause shares rose on Wednesday.
“With indicators of stabilization within the subscriber base rising, we consider the prospect of a chronic interval of subscriber losses is changing into more and more unlikely,” Stifel analyst Scott Devitt mentioned in a be aware to purchasers. Stifel upgraded its ranking on Netflix shares to “purchase” on Wednesday.
However the results, which some investors found good enough, could solely result in short-term reduction. The bear case for Netflix is that Wednesday’s bump in share worth is a “lifeless cat bounce” − Wall Road lingo for a short lived restoration after a considerable fall. Netflix faces intensifying competitors from main gamers pushing into the streaming market, together with Disney’s Disney+, NBCUniversal’s Peacock and HBO Max. That has raised questions on whether or not Netflix will be capable to maintain onto its dominance, notably within the profitable U.S. market.
Beforehand, Netflix bulls have leaned in to the notion that the corporate would flip its huge world scale of 221 million subscribers into constructive free money circulate by rising pricing and decreasing churn. This transformation from a money-losing enterprise to a free money circulate machine would enrich shareholders.
That is now occurred, or, at the least, is about to occur. Netflix mentioned in its shareholder letter it can generate $1 billion in free money circulate for 2022. In 2023, Netflix mentioned there might be “substantial development” in free money circulate.
And but, Netflix shares are nonetheless buying and selling 70% decrease than all-time highs set in November.
A second wave of subscriber development could possibly be the corporate’s new narrative for traders. There’s cause to consider Netflix subscribers will as soon as once more surge forward. Netflix introduced it can crack down on password sharing and launch a less expensive promoting supported tier in 2023. Each of these initiatives could result in extra signups.
If Netflix’s subscriber development would not reaccelerate, the second quarter of 2022 will function the inflection level when it turned obvious the corporate’s halcyon days have been over.
“The place do its sub losses finish, given sturdy competitors from newer, lower-priced, deeper-pocketed, streaming providers?,” wrote Needham analyst Laura Martin. “222 million world subs could change into the height subscribers for Netflix.”
This will likely show to be the case if Netflix cannot flip sufficient of its password sharers into long-term paying subscribers. Netflix mentioned in its shareholder letter that is it is inspired by its early learnings from exams in Latin America that it may possibly convert password-sharers to paying prospects.
In Tuesday’s convention name, Netflix Chief Monetary Officer Spencer Neumann mentioned the corporate deliberate to spend about $17 billion on content material in 2022 and would keep in that “zip code” for the subsequent “few years.” That is a change from practically yearly up to now decade, when Netflix has ramped up content material spending to construct its market share. As its income development has slowed, Neumann acknowledged spending on new programming will even average.
“Our content material expense will proceed to develop, nevertheless it’s extra moderated as we adjusted for the expansion in our income,” mentioned Neumann.
It stays to be seen if Netflix can proceed to develop its subscriber base with out an ever-ballooning content material price range — particularly because the firm usually raises costs annually. The fear is especially stark within the U.S. and Canada, the place Netflix misplaced 1.3 million subscribers within the second quarter, marking the third quarter within the final 5 when its buyer base has declined.
“Given the chance of elevated churn with each worth hike from right here, the practical fear is that the corporate might be laborious pressed to materially re-accelerate development in these areas,” mentioned Michael Nathanson, an analyst at analysis agency MoffettNathanson.
In coming years, traders could look again on this yr’s second quarter because the second Netflix both started its second development act or its slow migration into a value stock.
WATCH: CNBC’s Jim Cramer on Netflix